Tuesday, August 4, 2009
Seattle's Open (sort-of) Government
An article, “Seattle City Council is Not as Committed to Open Government as it Claims,” appeared in the August 4, 2009 Seattle Times, and is available at http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/opinion/2009592681_guest04leman.html
The author, Chris Leman, can be reached at cleman@oo.net
A March 1, 2009 radio interview with Leman on KBCS provides further background about the City Council and open government: http://bellevuecollege.edu/kbcs/downloads/One_World_Report/OWR_20090226/OWR_20090226_Open_Government_PMHT.mp3.
A February 24, 2009 Seattle Community Council Federation letter to the City Council’s Special Committee on Open Government is available at http://seattlefederation.blogspot.com/2009_03_01_archive.html
The next meeting of this City Council committee is Friday, August 7, 2009 at 2 p.m. in the City Council chambers, second floor of City Hall at 601 Fifth Avenue in downtown Seattle. The agenda, which includes a 2 p.m. public comment period, is available at http://seattle.gov/council/agendasc/opengov.pdf
The author, Chris Leman, can be reached at cleman@oo.net
A March 1, 2009 radio interview with Leman on KBCS provides further background about the City Council and open government: http://bellevuecollege.edu/kbcs/downloads/One_World_Report/OWR_20090226/OWR_20090226_Open_Government_PMHT.mp3.
A February 24, 2009 Seattle Community Council Federation letter to the City Council’s Special Committee on Open Government is available at http://seattlefederation.blogspot.com/2009_03_01_archive.html
The next meeting of this City Council committee is Friday, August 7, 2009 at 2 p.m. in the City Council chambers, second floor of City Hall at 601 Fifth Avenue in downtown Seattle. The agenda, which includes a 2 p.m. public comment period, is available at http://seattle.gov/council/agendasc/opengov.pdf
Tuesday, July 21, 2009
SEATTLE COMMUNITY COUNCIL FEDERATION
Regular Meeting
NOAA (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Agency), Pacific Marine Center on Lake Union
1801 Fairview Avenue East
http://seattlefederation.blogspot.com/
Thursday, July 23, 2009
AGENDA
A Dialogue with Parks Superintendent Tim Gallagher
Regular Meeting
NOAA (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Agency), Pacific Marine Center on Lake Union
1801 Fairview Avenue East
http://seattlefederation.blogspot.com/
Thursday, July 23, 2009
AGENDA
A Dialogue with Parks Superintendent Tim Gallagher
Seattle Parks and Recreation is committed to maintaining safe and welcoming environments and offering programming and services that are relevant neighbors. So, how is the Parks Department doing? Are the needs of your community being addressed? Is the Department responsive to your concerns regarding the many issues that arise? The Department’s Strategic Action Plan establishes a vision and guide for decision-making for a five-year period. How is it working? How are things progressing with passage of the 2008 Parks and Green Spaces Levy? Is the synthetic turf policy appropriate for our parks? These are a sampling of the issues that will be addressed with featured guest Parks Superintendent Tim Gallagher at the July Federation meeting.
The July meeting will also include our monthly Round Robin of issues and projects in your neighborhood. It is your opportunity to brief our citywide membership about what you are working on and to share perceptions on what is going right and what isn’t with our city government.
If you have informational materials you would like distributed at the meeting, please email electronic copies or links to Jeannie Hale at jeannieh@serv.net.
7:00 Call to Order and Introductions
Administration
1. Changes to the agenda
2. Treasurer’s report
3. President’s report
7:15 Round Robin
1. Neighborhood Planning Advisory Committee—Update
2. Proposed Comprehensive Plan Amendments—Update
3. Should the Federation take a position on the Housing Levy?
4. Other issues/projects
8:00 A Dialogue with Parks Superintendent Tim Gallagher
9:00 Adjourn
NOAA is a federal facility on high security alert, so attendees must enter by the security gate and may need to present photo ID. If you haven't attended a recent Federation meeting, please send your name, contact information, and address to rickbarrett@gmail.com to be added to the entry list. No e-mail? Call 206-365-1267. The building is ADA compliant, with ample parking in front.
Monday, July 6, 2009
INVITE: Status Check: How is your Neighborhood Doing? Meeting series hosted by the Seattle Planning Commission & Neighborhood Planning Advisory Committee.
Note - At our June Federation meeting we heard from two neighborhoods that have just completed this process. They report that their perception is that the City is apparently attempting to ignore/revise existing Neighborhood Plans. Since then we have received another message on this subject from a third neighborhood: “The neighborhood plan updating process is already under way in three neighborhoods: North Beacon Hill, North Rainier Valley, and Othello/New Holly. Two rounds of community meetings have been held in each of these three neighborhoods. The city is now expanding the program with a round of meetings in several other areas of the city. Some of us with an interest in our neighborhoods have found the process challenging. Meetings are called but with no agenda included. Weeks pass in between meetings with no feedback received from the City. The [new] process appears to be the opposite of what we experienced in the 1990's -- top-down and City-driven as opposed to bottom-up and neighborhood driven."
Your Neighborhood needs to be represented at these meetings.
Please attend with a copy of your Neighborhood Plan and be prepared to defend it.
REMINDER - The meeting for Lake City, Aurora/Licton Springs, Broadview - Bitter Lake - Haller Lake, University Community is scheduled for Wednesday July 8th from 6-8 p.m. Northgate Community Center 10510 5th Ave. N
Materials for this meeting are now available for viewing on-line at http://www.seattle.gov/dpd/Planning/Neighborhood_Planning/StatusReports
For those who cannot attend check out our virtual on-line meeting and take our quick questionnaire to make sure your voice is heard. Click here to watch a brief video, view your neighborhood summary and take the questionnaire!!!
http://www.cityofseattle.net/planningcommission/
More Neighborhoods are coming soon...so keep checking back
Please join members of the Seattle Planning Commission and the Neighborhood Planning Advisory Committee in the first of a series of two important community meetings.
These two citizen groups want to hear your thoughts. Come and tell us how your neighborhood has changed since your neighborhood plan was adopted. Your comments and input at this meeting will help the City of Seattle complete a status report that will look at how well your neighborhood plan is achieving its goals and strategies.
This first series of meetings will provide an opportunity to learn about your neighborhood plan, the projects that have been implemented, and growth and changes that have occurred since the plan was written in the late 90's. We will explore issues such as growth, transportation, housing, economic development , basic utilities, neighborhood character, open space and parks, public services, public safety, and other issues.
The second meeting series, tentatively scheduled for October, will be an opportunity to review the status report.
Dates and locations for Series One - Neighborhood Status Report Updates. Join the meeting that includes your community
June 22nd
For Queen Anne, Belltown, Eastlake, Capitol Hill, First Hill, Pike/Pine
6-8 p.m.
South Lake Union Armory 860 Terry Ave N.
July 8th
For Lake City, Aurora/Licton Springs, Broadview - Bitter Lake - Haller Lake, University Community
6-8 p.m.
Northgate Community Center 10510 5th Ave. NE
July 23rd
For Greenwood/Phinney, Crown Hill & Ballard, Fremont, Wallingford, Green Lake
6-8 p.m.
Phinney Neighborhood Center 6532 Phinney Ave. N
July 27th
For Central Area (Madison-Miller, 23rd & Union - Jackson and 12th Avenue), Columbia City - Hillman City - Genesee, Rainier Beach
6-8 p.m
Rainier Community Center Gym 4600 38th Ave. S
July 28th
For Admiral, West Seattle Junction, Morgan Junction, Delridge, Westwood/Highland Park, Georgetown
6-8 p.m
Delridge Community Center Gym 4501 Delridge Way SW
With questions please contact Planning Commission staff at (206) 684-8694 or mail to katie.sheehy@seattle.gov
Barbara E. Wilson
Seattle Planning Commission
Executive Director
(206) 684-0431
mail to: Barb.wilson@seattle.gov
Note - At our June Federation meeting we heard from two neighborhoods that have just completed this process. They report that their perception is that the City is apparently attempting to ignore/revise existing Neighborhood Plans. Since then we have received another message on this subject from a third neighborhood: “The neighborhood plan updating process is already under way in three neighborhoods: North Beacon Hill, North Rainier Valley, and Othello/New Holly. Two rounds of community meetings have been held in each of these three neighborhoods. The city is now expanding the program with a round of meetings in several other areas of the city. Some of us with an interest in our neighborhoods have found the process challenging. Meetings are called but with no agenda included. Weeks pass in between meetings with no feedback received from the City. The [new] process appears to be the opposite of what we experienced in the 1990's -- top-down and City-driven as opposed to bottom-up and neighborhood driven."
Your Neighborhood needs to be represented at these meetings.
Please attend with a copy of your Neighborhood Plan and be prepared to defend it.
REMINDER - The meeting for Lake City, Aurora/Licton Springs, Broadview - Bitter Lake - Haller Lake, University Community is scheduled for Wednesday July 8th from 6-8 p.m. Northgate Community Center 10510 5th Ave. N
Materials for this meeting are now available for viewing on-line at http://www.seattle.gov/dpd/Planning/Neighborhood_Planning/StatusReports
For those who cannot attend check out our virtual on-line meeting and take our quick questionnaire to make sure your voice is heard. Click here to watch a brief video, view your neighborhood summary and take the questionnaire!!!
http://www.cityofseattle.net/planningcommission/
More Neighborhoods are coming soon...so keep checking back
Please join members of the Seattle Planning Commission and the Neighborhood Planning Advisory Committee in the first of a series of two important community meetings.
These two citizen groups want to hear your thoughts. Come and tell us how your neighborhood has changed since your neighborhood plan was adopted. Your comments and input at this meeting will help the City of Seattle complete a status report that will look at how well your neighborhood plan is achieving its goals and strategies.
This first series of meetings will provide an opportunity to learn about your neighborhood plan, the projects that have been implemented, and growth and changes that have occurred since the plan was written in the late 90's. We will explore issues such as growth, transportation, housing, economic development , basic utilities, neighborhood character, open space and parks, public services, public safety, and other issues.
The second meeting series, tentatively scheduled for October, will be an opportunity to review the status report.
Dates and locations for Series One - Neighborhood Status Report Updates. Join the meeting that includes your community
June 22nd
For Queen Anne, Belltown, Eastlake, Capitol Hill, First Hill, Pike/Pine
6-8 p.m.
South Lake Union Armory 860 Terry Ave N.
July 8th
For Lake City, Aurora/Licton Springs, Broadview - Bitter Lake - Haller Lake, University Community
6-8 p.m.
Northgate Community Center 10510 5th Ave. NE
July 23rd
For Greenwood/Phinney, Crown Hill & Ballard, Fremont, Wallingford, Green Lake
6-8 p.m.
Phinney Neighborhood Center 6532 Phinney Ave. N
July 27th
For Central Area (Madison-Miller, 23rd & Union - Jackson and 12th Avenue), Columbia City - Hillman City - Genesee, Rainier Beach
6-8 p.m
Rainier Community Center Gym 4600 38th Ave. S
July 28th
For Admiral, West Seattle Junction, Morgan Junction, Delridge, Westwood/Highland Park, Georgetown
6-8 p.m
Delridge Community Center Gym 4501 Delridge Way SW
With questions please contact Planning Commission staff at (206) 684-8694 or mail to katie.sheehy@seattle.gov
Barbara E. Wilson
Seattle Planning Commission
Executive Director
(206) 684-0431
mail to: Barb.wilson@seattle.gov
Wednesday, June 24, 2009
2nd working draft 04/16/09
Credit: Denver, where growing citizens is the first order of business
http://www.newcodedenver.org/rezoning/page/why-how-and-when
Areas of Change—in Seattle —designated urban centers, industrial centers and urban village are the places where new investment would be the most beneficial, and increased density and change of use is appropriate.
Areas of Stability—in Seattle—are all the established residential neighborhoods outside of designated villages and centers where reinvestment and change will occur while the density and type of use will remain largely as it is, unless otherwise designated by a Council adopted neighborhood plan.
Articulated, Articulation mean clear and distinct expression of the joinery or various construction elements of a building in a way that enriches the sense of the whole as experienced by the pedestrian. Traditional buildings acknowledge pedestrian speed with flat wall planes quietly articulated.
Context is the elements which, taken together, comprise a built environment. Context elements include street, block, and lot patterns, as well as land use, and building form and scale.
Context-based Zoning derives zoning regulations from the desirable attributes or development characteristics of existing neighborhoods or planned places (i.e., the "context").
Density is the permitted concentration of residential units in an area of land, or the permitted ratio of building size to land area when there are additional uses or uses other than residential units.
Design Departure—in Seattle— is a formal request to depart from one or more development standards (see) listed in the zoning code as a standard from which, and in consideration of separately published design guidelines (see design standards), departure is allowed. The review process varies depending on the size of the project.
Design Standards are requirements that set a development's appearance and its visual and functional relation to existing or future neighbors. If the word standards is used they are considered development standards (see) and must be as objective as possible. Design requirements associated with conditional approval should be identified as the criteria upon which the conditional approval would be based. Occasionally Seattle has listed conditional criteria within the zoning code, currently it uses separately published design guidelines for discretionary decision-making when projects exceed certain size thresholds and for design departure requests (see).
Development Standards comprise all the requirements that if followed in total and to the letter will result in the issuance of a building permit “as of right,” meaning one has a legal right to that assumption.
Flexible is the opposite of predictable, which is a primary objective of zoning. Odd as it may seem, nature includes zoning codes, so zoning codes need a simple way to protect DNA yet allow change. The measure of a good code is the grace with which it accomplishes both.
Form-Based Zoning emphasizes regulation of building "form" (versus just "use") to assure a building's general shape, massing, height and orientation positively contribute to the existing or desired neighborhood context.
Mixed Use Zoning allows mixing of different land uses, such as residential, retail and office, either in the same building or in the same district/area.
Predictable refers to the primary objective of zoning as in “consistent, predictable, and clear” so as to promote community reinvestment by providing a public form of investment security, especially for those whose primary investment is a home or small business property.
Principles of Zoning are the same two fundamentals of democracy that guide all areas of governmental decision-making—equal protection and due process. All else is technique. Equal protection means equal treatment of persons similarly situated so that a citizen can reasonably predict what the public response will be to his private acts. Due process means a layman is readily able to check the consistency or irresponsibility of public decisions in specific cases.
Rezoning is an action of the City Council to amend the zoning map designation of a property or area, either “upzoning” if the designation is toward more intense development, or “downzoning” if the action is toward less intensity.
Sustainable refers to the long-term social, economic and environmental health of a community.
Transparent means easy to understand, patently fair and obvious.
Transparency, associated with walkable communities, is the total glazed area located on a street-facing story of a building, usually the ground story, divided by the total wall area of that street-facing story.
Multi-Modal refers to giving travelers more choices than simply using their cars, such as rail and bus transit, car pools, walking, biking, and shuttle service.
Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) aims regulation of land use and design at beautiful, vital, walkable, and affordable new or recycled urban neighborhoods that provide housing, shopping and transportation choices as well as access to the region's jobs, government centers, healthcare facilities and cultural and recreational destinations.
Use-Based Zoning emphasizes regulating the use of buildings or land to assure compatible development within an area or district. Most zoning in the United States remains predominately use-based with mixed-use zones increasingly designated. See, in comparison, "form-based zoning."
Zoning Code is the body of local laws governing what can be built on a property, as well as how it can be used.
The Seattle Citizens' Guide
to
What One Can Do On One's Land
to
What One Can Do On One's Land
Glossary
for
understanding the talk about zoning issues
understanding the talk about zoning issues
Credit: Denver, where growing citizens is the first order of business
http://www.newcodedenver.org/rezoning/page/why-how-and-when
Areas of Change—in Seattle —designated urban centers, industrial centers and urban village are the places where new investment would be the most beneficial, and increased density and change of use is appropriate.
Areas of Stability—in Seattle—are all the established residential neighborhoods outside of designated villages and centers where reinvestment and change will occur while the density and type of use will remain largely as it is, unless otherwise designated by a Council adopted neighborhood plan.
Articulated, Articulation mean clear and distinct expression of the joinery or various construction elements of a building in a way that enriches the sense of the whole as experienced by the pedestrian. Traditional buildings acknowledge pedestrian speed with flat wall planes quietly articulated.
Context is the elements which, taken together, comprise a built environment. Context elements include street, block, and lot patterns, as well as land use, and building form and scale.
Context-based Zoning derives zoning regulations from the desirable attributes or development characteristics of existing neighborhoods or planned places (i.e., the "context").
Density is the permitted concentration of residential units in an area of land, or the permitted ratio of building size to land area when there are additional uses or uses other than residential units.
Design Departure—in Seattle— is a formal request to depart from one or more development standards (see) listed in the zoning code as a standard from which, and in consideration of separately published design guidelines (see design standards), departure is allowed. The review process varies depending on the size of the project.
Design Standards are requirements that set a development's appearance and its visual and functional relation to existing or future neighbors. If the word standards is used they are considered development standards (see) and must be as objective as possible. Design requirements associated with conditional approval should be identified as the criteria upon which the conditional approval would be based. Occasionally Seattle has listed conditional criteria within the zoning code, currently it uses separately published design guidelines for discretionary decision-making when projects exceed certain size thresholds and for design departure requests (see).
Development Standards comprise all the requirements that if followed in total and to the letter will result in the issuance of a building permit “as of right,” meaning one has a legal right to that assumption.
Flexible is the opposite of predictable, which is a primary objective of zoning. Odd as it may seem, nature includes zoning codes, so zoning codes need a simple way to protect DNA yet allow change. The measure of a good code is the grace with which it accomplishes both.
Form-Based Zoning emphasizes regulation of building "form" (versus just "use") to assure a building's general shape, massing, height and orientation positively contribute to the existing or desired neighborhood context.
Mixed Use Zoning allows mixing of different land uses, such as residential, retail and office, either in the same building or in the same district/area.
Predictable refers to the primary objective of zoning as in “consistent, predictable, and clear” so as to promote community reinvestment by providing a public form of investment security, especially for those whose primary investment is a home or small business property.
Principles of Zoning are the same two fundamentals of democracy that guide all areas of governmental decision-making—equal protection and due process. All else is technique. Equal protection means equal treatment of persons similarly situated so that a citizen can reasonably predict what the public response will be to his private acts. Due process means a layman is readily able to check the consistency or irresponsibility of public decisions in specific cases.
Rezoning is an action of the City Council to amend the zoning map designation of a property or area, either “upzoning” if the designation is toward more intense development, or “downzoning” if the action is toward less intensity.
Sustainable refers to the long-term social, economic and environmental health of a community.
Transparent means easy to understand, patently fair and obvious.
Transparency, associated with walkable communities, is the total glazed area located on a street-facing story of a building, usually the ground story, divided by the total wall area of that street-facing story.
Multi-Modal refers to giving travelers more choices than simply using their cars, such as rail and bus transit, car pools, walking, biking, and shuttle service.
Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) aims regulation of land use and design at beautiful, vital, walkable, and affordable new or recycled urban neighborhoods that provide housing, shopping and transportation choices as well as access to the region's jobs, government centers, healthcare facilities and cultural and recreational destinations.
Use-Based Zoning emphasizes regulating the use of buildings or land to assure compatible development within an area or district. Most zoning in the United States remains predominately use-based with mixed-use zones increasingly designated. See, in comparison, "form-based zoning."
Zoning Code is the body of local laws governing what can be built on a property, as well as how it can be used.
Mayor’s Proposals Still Don't Fix the Townhouse Mess,
Still Lead to New Messes
Still Lead to New Messes
“Mayor Nickels is proposing amendments to the multifamily chapter of the City’s Land Use Code, to promote smart growth, green housing and good design. The new Multifamily Code proposal advances the City’s growth management objectives and better achieves the City’s goals and policies for new development, and makes the code easier to use and understand.”
http://www.seattle.gov/council/clark/2009townhomes.htm
Lead paragraph of DPD Director Report @ “Important Links”:
“Overall, the [Planning] Commission supports the goals of the Multifamily Zoning Update, but it is not clear that the proposed code changes achieve them.“
http://www.seattle.gov/council/Clark/attachments/2009multifam_zone_update.pdf
Lead paragraph @ Planning Commission's General Comments
“Almost everyone...recognizes that the existing code is virtually impossible to understand due to its form and complex amendment history”
--Report on Zoning Code reform options, prepared for City of Seattle, 1977, Joyce, Copeland, etc., Architects
Lead Quote in Land Use Code Simplification Issues/Options, prepared for City of Seattle, 1998, Nancy Fox.
[Multifamily Update/Amendments is supposedly an outcome of the 1998 “Simplification.”]
The current amendments (dated September 2008), unlike releases in November 2007 and July 2008, made it to the City Council and are being deliberated in three separate parts: first Lowrise, then Midrise, then Highrise. The Lowrise amendments are the subject of this paper.
The only obvious changes between the current draft and prior drafts are several rewordings in the “Locational Criteria Section.” The major substantive change occurred between the November 2007 draft and the July 2008 draft: a decision to abandon upward revision of the height limit in the three lowest intensity multifamily zones and to retain the current limit of25,' plus 10' within a pitched roof of 6”of rise in 12” of run. There is evidence however that the Mayor may be punting on this issue:
• Planning Commission in ref. above: “Height limit should be at least 30 feet in LDT, L1 and L2; it does not make sense to have a lower limit than is allowed in SF,”
• Councilmember Conlin: sponsoring Sunset Hill's proposal to reduce the SF height limit to match the LDT, L1, and L2, yet following “architects” (per press) advice to skip that part even after July draft retained lower heights in MF.
•Architects (CORA) lobbying PLUNC committee Apr, 8.2009 for raising the heights.
Where are we? Where to we want to go? We currently have a set of Lowrise Multifamily development standards that are a far better neighborhood design code than the Mayor's Proposal, even after nearly two decades of hair-splitting amendments. How so? Because they were adopted at citizen instigation in late 1989 to correct failed 1982 amendments ironically similar to the currently proposed amendments. Unaware of this fact, Council committee chair Clark's website repeats the planners' claim to be amending the work of 1982.
For well over three decades, Seattle legislators have actively promoted the townhouse, a housing type stubbornly not built in Seattle. So the current surplus of ill-planned townhouses is a definite first. It is also an easy to fix glitch. The double rowed “packs” are unintended consequence of townhouse code advantages, but they would not have occurred without intentional administrative interpretations playing to what turned out to be not a housing shortage, but an ownership mania.
In June 2008, the Seattle Community Council Federation held a townhouse workshop and adopted a resolution calling for the city to immediately enact an emergency ordinance placing interim restrictive controls on townhouses, and then really address the numerous Council directives for a more accessible code—one that is easy to administer, yet remains a design code that focuses on the way buildings fit together with their neighbors—and at the same time genuinely encourages good design.
The Mayor's response:
In July 2008, the Mayor announced in a press conference that the townhouse glitch was resolved through administrative design review and that his new code was simpler because it increased flexibility. Unfortunately, for neighbors “flexible” also means unpredictable, at least to those not interested in developable square feet, unit counts, and capacities. The Mayor 's proposal reduces design to a very brief, very nanny-state set of inflexible design standards for only the fronts of only small buildings.
The Mayor's full text reveals the Mayor's proposal still would:
1. Not fix the townhouse glitch.
2. Not stop “micropermitting” where a larger development is broken into many small permits in order to avoid street improvements and required design and environmental reviews.
3. Reincarnate Mayor Royer's 1982 apartment house disaster (it reverts to the same or worse numbers)
4. Focus on ratios and other means of calculating capacity and the value of property instead of on the livability and long term appeal of the new buildings.
5. Wipe out the current focus on how buildings relate to their neighbors in terms of form and function.
6. Wipe out the investment security of property owners by destroying physical predictability, except through zoning, an uninsurable public property— see Fischel (1985 through 2001) http://www.dartmouth.edu/~wfischel/
7. Increase allowed lot coverage’s at the expense of natural vegetation and natural stormwater infiltration— least cost, most effective ecological responses.
8. Replace clear and concise rezoning criteria with vague criteria so that upzones anywhere become unchallengeable, doing away with the urban village strategy of matching development with infrastructure to produce livable urban communities.
9. Set the stage, with #8 above, for selling upzones, a new and untried concept in Seattle and, as a corollary, make corrective downzones prohibitively expensive.
What is administrative design review?
Copies of old codes reveal a minor Seattle tradition—Councils proceed with uncertain land use amendments by subjecting a dubious situation to special criteria and discretionary review.
Two examples: 1. townhouses pre 1982, and 2. a “mixed density” zone for the Regrade (both examples worthy of further study).
But in the main, each zone sets forth certain uses as “allowed outright” meaning that approval to build can not be withheld (is “as-of-right”) if all stated requirements are satisfied— albeit requirements are increasingly complex and projects above a moderate size are also subjected to mandatory, discretionary environmental and design review.
In 1998, a second tier came into being that allowed departure from an array of requirements (the array itself has frequently changed) —known either as Voluntary Administrative Design Review or Design Departure. Mayoral proposals since 1980 proposed many versions, but finally, Ordinance #118980 under Councilmember Drago's sponsorship added to the Municipal Code: 23.41.004 B. Design Review-Optional, and 23.41.016 Administrative Design Review Process . Overnight, Seattle had a two tier land use code, the existing code comprising the first tier, and optional, negotiated departure comprising the second tier. An intentional two-tier code makes a lot of sense. Development standards lay out a foolproof first tier under which everyday projects do little damage and can be promptly permitted. Sound criteria for negotiated departures offers a second more strenuous track that not only furthers good design, project by project, but good code development as well.
But good intentions have a habit of getting lost over time. First of all, the present inclination and code have little to do with either foolproof or speedy permitting. Second, what the Mayor proposed back in July of 2008 is the opposite of an optional, more strenuous track. The proposal, not included in the package to Council, would add a new mandatory design review of all townhouses to either the workload of the present voluntary administrative review staff or the permitting staff, the same staff, untrained in design, that created the townhouse mess in the first place through misguided focus on “we need the housing.”(Stranger, July 18, 2007)
The real horror is that there is not yet anything, nothing, no authority in the Mayor's Amendments, or any existing design guideline, that would allow any reviewer to fix the townhouse glitch. We would still have with us:
1. Cramming too many townhouse units into former yards. Worse, instead of removing the townhouse incentives, the Mayor proposes extending them to apartments. This would bulk up apartment buildings again outside villages to conditions beyond those of the mid 1980s.
2. Cramming too many units too close to neighbors. The proposal is to turn all “yards” into setbacks varying between 5' and 7,' except where adjacent to a Single Family zone and to only limit building widths and lengths on very large lots.
3. Compromised neighborhood safety. One fire will make all too clear that urban neighborhoods composed of dead-ended, auto-courted, tandem rows of unsprinklered wood-frame townhouses are but the modern version of the tenement, justified as essential to employment prior to motorized transportation.
4. Inadequate driveways, turning radii, turn-arounds, and too low overhangs, resulting in over-burdened street parking and restricted fire department access.
5. Speculators, profit-focused builders able to outbid anyone interested in either the existing ground-related housing or quality design. In booms: accelerated loss of pleasant, affordable neighborhoods and their replacement with less affordable housing of short-term appeal. In busts: the lost potential, a drag on the market, i.e. the current excess of ill-planned townhouses.
6.Use of bad manners to impact neighboring property and encourage forced sales.
Still valid—the Federation’s resolution calling for simple emergency interim controls to stop ill-planned townhouses followed by moderating standards and cleaning up means of departure to assure that both everyday and leading-edge buildings are good neighbors in appealing neighborhoods.
The City Council will need to hear from you on this.
A. Nissen (Nissen/Nissen Architect) by request, 06/09
Tuesday, June 23, 2009
SEATTLE COMMUNITY COUNCIL FEDERATION
Regular Meeting
NOAA (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Agency), Pacific Marine Center on Lake Union
1801 Fairview Avenue East
http://seattlefederation.blogspot.com/
Thursday, June 25, 2009
AGENDA
Can Seattle Afford to Renew the Housing Levy?
Regular Meeting
NOAA (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Agency), Pacific Marine Center on Lake Union
1801 Fairview Avenue East
http://seattlefederation.blogspot.com/
Thursday, June 25, 2009
AGENDA
Can Seattle Afford to Renew the Housing Levy?
Seattle voters will be asked to approve a $145 million housing levy on the November ballot. The measure is expected to cost the owner of a $430,000 home $79 a year in property taxes over the seven year life of the levy (an increase from the previous levy that cost that homeowner $49 annually).
The monies raised will contribute to the production of at least 1600 additional units of low-income housing in our community. If the measure passes, it would be the fourth successive seven-year levy garnering voter approval since 1988. Over $200 million has been raised from past levies, which produced over 4000 low-income units. Without this critical resource, literally thousands of folks would have been rendered homeless and/or forced out of our communities due to rising rents and displacement. But, in these difficult economic times, can residents afford the cost? Come hear details about the proposed levy from those most knowledgeable about the proposal.
The June meeting will also include our monthly Round Robin of issues and projects in your neighborhood. It is your opportunity to brief our citywide membership about what you are working on and to share perceptions on what is going right and what isn’t with our city government.
If you have informational materials you would like distributed at the meeting, please email electronic copies or links to Jeannie Hale at jeannieh@serv.net.
7:00 Call to Order and Introductions
Administration
1. Changes to the agenda
2. Treasurer’s report
3. President’s report
7:15 Can Seattle Afford to Renew the Housing Levy?
8:00 Round Robin
1. Neighborhood Planning Advisory Committee—Status Report: How well are the City’s 24 neighborhood plans responding to issues such as growth, transportation, housing, economic development, open space, public safety and other issues?
2. Multi-Family Code Update
3. Other issues/projects
9:00 Adjourn
NOAA is a federal facility on high security alert, so attendees must enter by the security gate and may need to present photo ID. If you haven't attended a recent Federation meeting, please send your name, contact information, and address to rickbarrett@gmail.com to be added to the entry list. No e-mail? Call 206-365-1267. The building is ADA compliant, with ample parking in front.
Monday, June 22, 2009
SUMMER POTLUCK
Our May meeting agreed unanimously to accept the very generous offer of Dr. Glover Barnes to host our annual summer potluck at his home, 3415 S McClellan St, Seattle 98144 on Saturday, August 8th, 3 to 5 p.m.
Everyone is welcome.
Here’s a map.
Letter to the Editor
"Since I wrote to you this morning I have had a chance to read the draft [DADU] ordinance http//www/seattle.gov/dpd/Planning/BackyardCottages/Overview/ I believe that the SCCF might be incorrect in stating a few of the facts mentioned in your meeting minutes. It looks to me like the property owner is required to live on site when renting out a DADU and that a total of 8 people can be living on the property and the City will allow 50 permits per year (citywide) for new and/or conversion DADU's. Have you read the draft ordinance? I admit that I read it rather quickly and could have missed or misunderstood sections. I'd really appreciate your take on this whole DADU issue." May 14, 2009.
Editor's response: It's wise to consult the original document; the document speaks for itself. Sometimes, summaries differ from the text. Our newsletter tries to accurately report statements at a meeting.
A statement may err, the reporter may misunderstand or make errors in transcribing, or a shortage of space may result in too much editing.
Letters are welcome.
Our May meeting agreed unanimously to accept the very generous offer of Dr. Glover Barnes to host our annual summer potluck at his home, 3415 S McClellan St, Seattle 98144 on Saturday, August 8th, 3 to 5 p.m.
Everyone is welcome.
Here’s a map.
Letter to the Editor
"Since I wrote to you this morning I have had a chance to read the draft [DADU] ordinance http//www/seattle.gov/dpd/Planning/BackyardCottages/Overview/ I believe that the SCCF might be incorrect in stating a few of the facts mentioned in your meeting minutes. It looks to me like the property owner is required to live on site when renting out a DADU and that a total of 8 people can be living on the property and the City will allow 50 permits per year (citywide) for new and/or conversion DADU's. Have you read the draft ordinance? I admit that I read it rather quickly and could have missed or misunderstood sections. I'd really appreciate your take on this whole DADU issue." May 14, 2009.
Editor's response: It's wise to consult the original document; the document speaks for itself. Sometimes, summaries differ from the text. Our newsletter tries to accurately report statements at a meeting.
A statement may err, the reporter may misunderstand or make errors in transcribing, or a shortage of space may result in too much editing.
Letters are welcome.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)